Density of reliability roots of simple graphs in the unit disk
Brown and Colbourn showed that reliability roots of connected multigraphs are dense in the unit disk and that the closure of the real roots is [-1,0] ∪ {1}. A conjecture of Brown and McMullin asks for the same results for simple graphs.
The graphs C_m[K_n] are built by substituting each edge of a cycle C_m with a complete graph K_n. Their reliability polynomial factors through the reliability and split reliability polynomials of K_n. These are analyzed asymptotically, with Rel(K_n) tending to 1 and splitRel(K_n)/q^{n-1} tending to 2 uniformly on compact subsets of the open unit disk. A general lemma on zeros of f_n + m·g_n then gives the density result. The real-root density part was formalized in Lean 4; the complex part awaits a Lean formalization of Rouché's theorem.
Reliability roots of simple graphs are dense in the unit disk, and their real roots are dense in [-1,0], confirming the Brown–McMullin conjecture. The real-root statement is machine-checked in Lean 4. The paper also leaves open whether all reliability roots of complete graphs lie inside the unit disk.
