← All papers
First page of Classification of Conformally Covariant 2-Tensors from the Kulkarni–Nomizu Product in Dimension 4

Classification of Conformally Covariant 2-Tensors from the Kulkarni–Nomizu Product in Dimension 4

Yury N. Berdinsky

math-ph Sep 7, 2026 · v1
Lean 4 with Mathlib formally verifies the rank–nullity dimension count establishing the 2-dimensional classification space.
We classify all natural, conformally covariant, symmetric (0,2)-tensors of conformal weight -2 and differential order less than or equal to 4 in dimension 4, built from the metric, the Schouten tensor, covariant derivatives, and the Kulkarni-Nomizu product. We prove that the space of such tensors is exactly 2-dimensional, spanned by the Bach tensor (order 2) and the Eastwood-Singer tensor (order 4). The algebraic core is formally verified using Lean 4 with Mathlib. The 8x11 constraint matrix and divergence-free condition are verified computationally with exact rational arithmetic. Both English and Russian versions provided; Russian version available as ancillary.

Classify all natural, conformally covariant, symmetric (0,2)-tensors of conformal weight -2 and differential order at most 4 in dimension 4, built from the metric, Schouten tensor, covariant derivatives, and the Kulkarni–Nomizu product.

Eleven linearly independent candidate tensor terms are enumerated and the infinitesimal conformal covariance condition is imposed, producing an 8×11 algebraic constraint matrix plus a divergence-free condition. The matrix rank is verified over the rationals by exact Gaussian elimination in a Python script. The final dimension count via the rank–nullity theorem for linear maps between finite-dimensional real vector spaces is formally verified in Lean 4 with Mathlib.

The space of such tensors is exactly 2-dimensional, spanned by the order-2 Bach tensor and the order-4 Eastwood–Singer tensor (11 − 8 − 1 = 2).

#ExpressionOrderDescription
T1P_ab0Schouten tensor
T2(tr P) g_ab0Trace of P times metric
T3Δ P_ab2Laplacian of Schouten
T7Δ² P_ab4Bi-Laplacian of Schouten
T11(P⊙P)^c_{acb}0KN-product contraction
Candidate (0,2)-tensor terms (selection) of weight -2, order ≤ 4