Large gaps and BTZ entropy in modular spectra with positive integer degeneracies
Chi-Ming Chang, Reiko Liu, Wen-Jie Ma
hep-th
Sep 30, 2026 · v2
TL;DR
The two primary-gap theorems and the all-order smoothed BTZ entropy expansion are stated to have been formalized in Lean 4.
Abstract
We construct modular-invariant torus partition functions with a unique vacuum, discrete energy levels and positive integer degeneracies by recursively repairing the Maloney–Witten–Keller modular completion of the Virasoro vacuum. Exact modular repairs and finite moment matching discretize successive spectral bands while preserving earlier levels and controlling convergence. For $c_L=c_R=c$ and $a=(c-1)/12$, the construction realizes primary dimension gaps $Δ_1=(1+κ)a$ for sufficiently small fixed $κ>0$, and $Δ_1=a+δ$ for any fixed $δ\ge0$, at every sufficiently large real $c$. Every nonvacuum primary satisfies $h,\bar h\ge(c-1)/24$. In the fixed-$δ$ family, spectra can be chosen whose densities of states, smoothed with a fixed nonnegative normalized smooth kernel of compact support, match the correspondingly smoothed prediction of a single perturbative BTZ saddle through every fixed finite order in $1/c$. The count includes all spins and Virasoro descendants. Its logarithm reproduces the Bekenstein–Hawking entropy and its corrections at every fixed positive $E/c$, where $E=Δ-c/12$. This includes $0<E<c/12$, where thermal AdS dominates the canonical ensemble.
Problem
The Maloney–Witten–Keller modular completion of the Virasoro vacuum is modular invariant, but its spectrum is continuous and has negative densities. This blocks its interpretation as a compact unitary CFT partition function for pure AdS3 gravity.
Approach
The MWK completion is repaired recursively. Exact local modular repairs, built from a solved seed plus a threshold anchor, change the spectrum in a bounded energy band. Finite moment matching then replaces successive continuum cells with integer-multiplicity atoms while controlling higher-energy effects and convergence. The main gap theorems and the entropy expansion are formalized in Lean 4.
Results
For every sufficiently large real c, the construction gives modular-invariant spectra with a unique vacuum and positive integer degeneracies. All nonvacuum primaries satisfy h, h̄ ≥ (c−1)/24. Gaps of Δ1=(1+κ)a for small fixed κ>0 and Δ1=a+δ for any fixed δ≥0 are realized. In the fixed-δ family, the smoothed entropy matches the perturbative BTZ prediction to every finite order in 1/c at all fixed positive E/c.