← All papers
First page of Smale's mean value constant (1981) equals 4

Smale's mean value constant (1981) equals 4

Dave Goel

math.CV Nov 10, 2026 · v1
The main theorem, Smale's mean value constant equals 4, is formalized in Lean 4 and checked with the Lean comparator; a GitHub repository is provided.
For a complex polynomial $p$ of degree $d\ge 2$ with $p(0)=0$ and $p'(0)\ne 0$, let $S(p)$ be the minimum of $|p(c)/(c\,p'(0))|$ over the critical points $c$ of $p$, and let $K(d)$ be the supremum of $S(p)$ over all such $p$ of degree $d$. In 1981 Smale proved that $K(d)\le 4$ for every $d$, and asked whether $4$ can be replaced by $1$. We prove that Smale's mean value constant $\sup_dK(d)$ equals $4$ and that $K(d)\to4$ as $d\to\infty$, combining a reduction due to Jatar and Ng with an explicit construction. In particular, $4$ cannot be replaced by any smaller constant. Each $K(d)$ is known to be below $4$, so the supremum is not attained. The main result has also been formalized in the Lean 4 proof assistant.

Smale (1981) proved that for complex polynomials normalized with p(0)=0 and p'(0)≠0, some critical point c satisfies |p(c)/(c p'(0))| ≤ 4. He asked whether 4 can be replaced by 1. The problem is to determine the best constant K* = sup_d K(d).

A reduction due to Jatar and Ng turns the problem into constructing pairs of holomorphic functions on the disc, using Hilbert's lemniscate theorem. The authors build an explicit function F from an entire function composed with a conformal map onto a half strip, and a univalent map W built from logarithmic perturbations of the half-plane. They then apply this construction to rescaled Koebe functions. The main theorem is also formalized in Lean 4.

Smale's mean value constant K* equals 4, and K(d) → 4 as d → ∞, so 4 cannot be improved. Since each K(d) < 4, the supremum is not attained. The result is machine-checked in Lean 4.